How to Attract Early BFCM Shoppers: Holiday Content & SEO Guide for Sellers
Think Black Friday is when holiday shopping begins? Think again. Your future customers are already
The are two kinds of shoppers in this world. The first one buys things only when they need them which makes it easy to turn them into repeat customers. But the second one is driven by want and desire instead of need.
The second kind of shopper wants a unique and personalized experience. The kind of experience that they only find on websites like Etsy, a marketplace for personalized, handmade, and rare-to-find products made by skilled individuals.
And this high expectation makes it difficult to turn them into repeat clients. But we’ve got you covered. In this guide, we’ll show you how to gain repeat customers on Etsy this festive season and how to increase repeat customers even beyond the festive season.
This data from Statista shows that 40% of all Etsy customers are repeat clients. This is a very high number as far as the eCommerce repeat customer rate goes (between 20% to 40%).
We’ll give you 10 tips tailored for getting repeat customers on Etsy during the Holiday Season, but remember that you don’t have to incorporate every single one of them except a few which are detrimental to your business.
Let’s take a look at all the ways you can attract repeat clients to your Etsy Shop. Just remember that the key to this whole process is to build lasting relationships with your customers by making them feel valued and appreciated.
This should be a no-brainer if you already have an existing email list. Create a Festive newsletter series for your subscribers outlining which sales you’ll be running, when you’ll be running them, and what products (both new and existing) will be on sale.
Note: Don’t add your Etsy customers to your mailing list without first asking for their consent. It is against Etsy’s policies.
Emails are one of the highest organic ROI-producing channels and should be the first stage in your strategy for getting repeat customers on Etsy. According to a report by SaleCycle, 50% of all users who receive marketing emails end up making a purchase at least once a month.
So, if you already have an email list, start leveraging it by creating festive campaigns. If not, then you should think about incorporating email marketing in your long-term business and marketing plans.
Check Out our podcast where we talk about what products sell the most on Etsy.
Getting customers to buy from you, again and again, is about more than just having awesome products. It is also about giving them an awesome experience. Replying to your customers quickly (usually within an hour) makes them feel like you care about their queries.
And this is the kind of experience that helps you build positive relationships with your customers and makes them want to buy from you again. It is a simple yet powerful strategy to attract people to your business.
If you’ve ever received a surprise gift, even a small one, then you know exactly what we’re talking about. Getting freebies is just one of the things that make us happy to our core.
Receiving little freebies with their products fuels your customers’ desire to wanna buy from you again because it makes them feel special.
Something as little as chocolate or cookies or candy or festive-themed stickers fit the bill nicely. Remember that reciprocating is part of human behavior. The next time they’ll have to buy something similar, your shop will be the first one they’ll think of.
We think you might be starting to see the theme by now. It is all about making your customer feel wowed when it comes to getting repeat customers on Etsy.
Product packaging is one area of your business where you can be really creative, and it’s not even about making it feel expensive. Instead, it’s about making it feel well thought out. For example, if it’s Halloween, you can have Halloween-themed product packaging.
You can even show your unique packaging in your product images to pique the interest of your potential customers. Go to Pinterest and search for something along the lines of “Festive gift wrapping ideas” to get inspiration.
Do you know what’s the best way to show appreciation to your customers? It’s to tell them exactly that. This helps you in building a long-lasting relationship because everyone likes being appreciated every once in a while.
Just think of how many times you’ve received a heartfelt appreciation for doing business with a business. We’re quite sure that it happens very often. But it is a great way to build loyalty for your brand.
Check out this amazing webinar to master the Etsy Festive season sale
Just slip in a simple card with the product that essentially says “Thanks for supporting my business, I appreciate it and look forward to serving you again”. You’ll be surprised to see just how many people will reciprocate the appreciation by giving you positive reviews and/or shopping with you again.
Sometimes it may be possible that your customers might not know how to make the best use of your products. For example, they might not know the best ways to use your decoration item, or maybe they don’t know how to take care of the crochet doll they got for their kids.
This is an opportunity for you to go the extra mile and include instructions for your customers to use your products correctly and effectively and for taking care of the product. This will also let them come back and read stuff again if they ever need it.
Etsy’s Thank You Coupons are a great way to encourage your customers to come back shopping by offering them a discount code on their second purchase.
You can create these coupons using the built-in Sales and Coupons tool and by enabling the “Send as thank you” option. Etsy will automatically send these Thank You Coupons to your customers 24 hours after you mark their order as complete.
This is a non-negotiable thing if you want to get repeat customers on Etsy this festive season and perhaps even after that. Since there are a lot of orders being placed during the holiday season, sometimes things get messed up during the shipping process.
Maybe there’s a delay in the order, maybe the product gets damaged, maybe the shipment is lost, etc. There could be a lot of reasons for shipping mishaps. Your job is to be extra supportive to your customers who face any kind of shipping issue.
Remember that they chose to buy from you out of all the other shops, so it’s your responsibility to make sure they feel heard when things go wrong. You have to acknowledge that these situations are inevitable and every time you handle them poorly, you lose a potential life-long customer.
Handling these situations poorly also means that you’d get a bad review which ultimately decreases your customer and market experience score, which is something you wanna avoid at all costs.
There are many benefits of sharing behind the scene videos with your customers and audience, not the least of which is building long-lasting customer relationships.
Here are some of the things you can achieve by sharing behind the scene videos with your customers –
‘Etsy Updates’ is basically an Update feed on customers’ Etsy app that is designed to share notifications about your shop with those buyers who have interacted with your shop by either following it or favoriting your items.
The best part is that it is some of your actions that trigger the update feed. So for example, if you run a sale, send a coupon, etc. the customers will get notified about it and it increases the likelihood that they will visit your shop again.
Here are some examples of what you can do to trigger update notifications for buyers.
Whenever you run a sale, there are three possible notifications that can be sent to Etsy buyers –
Whenever you send a thank you coupon to your customers, they will receive the following notifications –
Whenever you add new items to your shop, the buyers will receive the following notification –
Whenever you restock an item in your shop, the buyers will receive the following notification –
Repeat customers are an integral part of any business whether it’s online or a brick & mortar store. The first and foremost thing to turn your Etsy customers into repeat customers is to delight them and make them feel special. Also, you need to remember that some things are more important than others like how you handle shipping mishaps. We hope that this guide gave you some insights that will help you grow your business.
Disclaimer– Etsy is a trademark of Etsy, Inc. This content is not created or endorsed by Etsy, Inc.
Think Black Friday is when holiday shopping begins? Think again. Your future customers are already
eBay is rolling out eBay Live in the UK, offering sellers a new way to
eBay is giving its auto parts and accessories marketplace a tune-up, announcing the launch of
Walmart is set to revamp its Pro Seller Program at the end of September 2025,
Pinterest is diving headfirst into the burgeoning secondhand market with the launch of “Thrift Shop,”
Why Pinterest Is a Growth Channel for Etsy Sellers Discovery drives eCommerce growth. With 482
In a strategic move to enable smaller businesses with global ambitions, international logistics giant DHL
In a turn of events that highlights the volatility and responsiveness of global eCommerce logistics,
About the Brand Name: Intense Oud Industry: Luxury Fragrance Location: US Luxury isn’t just a
Tariffs. AI-driven marketplace algorithms. The repeal of de minimis. And ad costs rise Y-O-Y. For
What’s Changing Beginning September 1, 2025, TikTok Shop will require all advertisers to run promotions
Amazon is making one of the biggest catalog cleanups in recent memory. Starting September 2,
Amazon Business is marking its 10th anniversary in 2025, celebrating a decade of transforming business
Best Buy has entered the growing “marketplace-as-a-service” trend by launching its first U.S. online marketplace
Etsy is experimenting with a new tiered ad strategy for sellers—currently in beta—that requires a
As announced, Amazon has officially opened submissions for its Prime Big Deal Days (October) and
Amazon is making grocery delivery more convenient than ever for its Prime members. As of
TikTok is no longer just shaping shopping trends—it’s now building the infrastructure to deliver them.
As eBay celebrates its 30th anniversary, the marketplace is doubling down on artificial intelligence to
eCommerce sellers, and those selling on Amazon, are entering a critical pre-Black Friday Cyber Monday